充气球 发表于 2025-3-23 11:21:15

http://reply.papertrans.cn/103/10282/1028161/1028161_11.png

Tinea-Capitis 发表于 2025-3-23 16:49:39

http://reply.papertrans.cn/103/10282/1028161/1028161_12.png

沉着 发表于 2025-3-23 21:09:55

http://reply.papertrans.cn/103/10282/1028161/1028161_13.png

涂掉 发表于 2025-3-24 01:18:02

Gareth B. Matthews,S. Marc CohenSocratic method of questioning and refutation (elenchus) predominates the early Platonic dialogues.Early dialogues were intended to commemorate Socrates and the elenchus.Uncovering the shortcomings th

彻底检查 发表于 2025-3-24 03:01:43

The Socratic Method, so-called Socratic elenchus. This is a species of philosophical analysis whose aim is to arrive at the definition of a problematic concept by means of subjecting alternative proposals to potential refutation by means of counterexample. Six key features of the method are delineated.

蕨类 发表于 2025-3-24 10:01:25

Analyzing Courage: ,, but Socrates shows them all to be defective. Their efforts end in perplexity, leading us to wonder whether the elenchus, as a form of inquiry, holds out a serious prospect of leading to the discovery of what courage is.

allergy 发表于 2025-3-24 13:50:42

Blameworthy Ignorance: ,are so dismal? We might hope to find an answer in the .. There we find a possible motivation for the elenchus in a principle of “epistemic purity”—the idea that one ought not to think one knows something that, in fact, one does not know.

Reclaim 发表于 2025-3-24 17:10:16

Virtue in Socratic Ignorance: , will ever be entirely satisfactory? The . may provide an answer, for it raises the possibility that the virtue that is the topic of this dialogue, . (self-mastery), may actually turn out to be the limited wisdom that Socrates claims to have, namely, self-knowledge.

痴呆 发表于 2025-3-24 20:47:13

http://reply.papertrans.cn/103/10282/1028161/1028161_19.png

倔强不能 发表于 2025-3-25 00:36:02

Conclusion,re are both internal and external limitations in what the elenchus can be reasonably expected to accomplish. And Plato also thought that philosophy can do more to get beyond those limitations. Only by going beyond the elenctic method will we be able to adequately address the foundational questions of philosophy.
页: 1 [2] 3 4 5
查看完整版本: Titlebook: Why Plato Lost Interest in the Socratic Method; Gareth B. Matthews,S. Marc Cohen Book 2023 The Editor(s) (if applicable) and The Author(s)