补助 发表于 2025-3-26 23:10:47
http://reply.papertrans.cn/43/4259/425811/425811_31.pngfrugal 发表于 2025-3-27 03:30:24
http://reply.papertrans.cn/43/4259/425811/425811_32.pngineluctable 发表于 2025-3-27 05:27:08
,Butterfield’s Critique of Acton,le Whig except Fox, who was no historian, or a single historian save Acton, who was no Whig’.. In the Preface Butterfield indicated that the subject was the whig interpretation in ‘the accepted meaning of the phrase’; a statement which drew from Carl C. Becker the confession that he ‘did not recallEmbolic-Stroke 发表于 2025-3-27 11:24:18
http://reply.papertrans.cn/43/4259/425811/425811_34.pngPopcorn 发表于 2025-3-27 13:36:39
Expository Historiography,f the relationship between these two standpoints is one of the central issues confronting the interpreter of Butterfield. In what respects was he a friend or a foe of whigs and whiggism? J. G. A. Pocock has described the reconciliation of the anti-progressivism of . with the celebration of the whigopportune 发表于 2025-3-27 19:24:00
http://reply.papertrans.cn/43/4259/425811/425811_36.pngCoronary 发表于 2025-3-27 22:37:01
Technical History,ative methodological particularism. On the contrary, his numerous references to providence seem to have prompted him to articulate with increased forthrightness the notion of a non-interpretative form of statement. As if to relativise the rest of the . lectures, ‘technical history’ was discussed inGuileless 发表于 2025-3-28 03:24:53
,Butterfield’s Critique of Interpretations,in particular. As a result, the weight of any such discussion lies primarily with whig historiography, rather than with the question of Butterfield’s concept and critique of interpretations as such. This question was only implicit in ., but became more explicit in the 1948–51 discussions concerningfender 发表于 2025-3-28 06:32:28
The Three Ways or Levels of History,technical history. It then also became necessary to establish the relationship between the writings that used providence as an explanatory device, and expository history, purporting to be the result of applying a strictly scientific generalising procedure to the concrete facts established by technic令人苦恼 发表于 2025-3-28 12:12:28
http://reply.papertrans.cn/43/4259/425811/425811_40.png