姑姑在炫耀 发表于 2025-3-28 15:44:52

http://reply.papertrans.cn/17/1616/161580/161580_41.png

自负的人 发表于 2025-3-28 21:43:40

The Assertoric Syllogistic in LPCThis way of representing Aristotle is often regarded with suspicion. It should not be, and I want to take this chapter to explain why it should not. Developing a modern LPC representation of Aristotle’s logic is straightforward, and so the reasons that are usually offered against this approach need

繁荣中国 发表于 2025-3-29 01:16:03

A Realm of Darknessunts. Albrecht Becker argues that the modal syllogistic falls apart because Aristotle makes a crucial mistake involving two different uses of .. (Becker 1933, pp. 41 – 43) Becker notices that Aristotle’s modal syllogisms appear to require that necessity acts as a qualifier on terms.

Arteriography 发表于 2025-3-29 05:13:18

Technicolour Termsthat ‘Aristotle’s doctrine of substance is integral to most of his philosophical work, not, however, to his strictly formal logic – a discipline which he inaugurated.’ (Anscombe 1961, p. vi) Whether or not Anscombe is correct it certainly seems clear that Aristotle thought that there could be no . s

熟练 发表于 2025-3-29 11:11:52

Representing the Modals denoted by X, a proposition about necessity by L, and a proposition about possibility by either M or Q depending on the kind of possibility involved. Thus, Barbara LLL is Barbara with premises and conclusion all necessary propositions, Barbara LXL is Barbara with the first premise a necessary propo

商谈 发表于 2025-3-29 13:01:01

http://reply.papertrans.cn/17/1616/161580/161580_46.png

semiskilled 发表于 2025-3-29 18:52:33

Against the Canonical Listings. are mainly A10 and A11. And I will follow Aristotle’s text closely in order to best explain the omissions I make – for there are differences between what Aristotle’s text requires and what an interpretive tradition requires. All the way through . A9–11, Aristotle gives a new and separate proof of

合唱团 发表于 2025-3-29 19:53:44

http://reply.papertrans.cn/17/1616/161580/161580_48.png

勾引 发表于 2025-3-30 00:19:15

http://reply.papertrans.cn/17/1616/161580/161580_49.png

considerable 发表于 2025-3-30 04:10:19

http://reply.papertrans.cn/17/1616/161580/161580_50.png
页: 1 2 3 4 [5] 6
查看完整版本: Titlebook: Aristotle‘s Modal Proofs; Prior Analytics A8-2 Adriane Rini Book 2011 Springer Science+Business Media B.V. 2011 Ancient logic.Aristotle.Mod